1. Blind Barber — East Village, Manhattan
A neighborhood barbershop with a bar behind it, and the shop that got the format right.
Blind Barber started in the East Village as a barbershop with a lounge behind it, and the reason it has lasted while imitators folded is that both halves are genuinely run — the cutting is not a gimmick attached to a bar, and the bar is not an afterthought attached to a shop. The grooming line that grew out of it is well regarded in its own right.
It is the easy recommendation for anyone new to the city who wants a reliable cut in a room that is pleasant to sit in. It is also the right answer for a group — a stag afternoon or a few friends before an evening out works here in a way it does not in a quiet shop.
Good to know: The lounge keeps different hours from the shop, so if the drink is part of the plan, check which you are booking around.